TikTok may face a ban in the United States after its hearing in the US Supreme Court on Friday went badly.
Judges appeared to be prefer the government’s argument that ownership of the app as an issue of national security, not free speech, according to a report by Eurasia Group’s GZero Daily on Monday, which noted that US lawmakers are concerned about the Chinese government having access to enormous amounts of Americans’ data – and fear the app could be used to spread Beijing’s agenda.
Other news outlets, such as The Hill, said that lawyers for the popular Chinese app “got a frosty reception” in their fight to stave off a ban.
ALSO SEE: Biden Restricts Access to AI Chips to US Firms And Its Allies
GZero noted that Facebook and other American social media platforms are banned in China, “with Beijing taking a similar view to that of the US government”. The justices seemed worried that TikTok could be used for espionage or even blackmail, it said.
Control of app seen as key issue, not free speech
Remarks by the Chief Justice, which were also reported in The Hill report, may be a pointer on how the appeal will go.
“Congress doesn’t care about what’s on TikTok. They don’t care about the [free] expression,” claimed Chief Justice John Roberts during questioning, clarifying “That’s shown by the remedy. They’re not saying TikTok has to stop. They’re saying the Chinese have to stop controlling TikTok.”
If the court rules against the app, it would mean TikTok’s parent company Bytedance must divest the company before January 19 or face a ban in the United States on national security grounds, GZero said. The app would no longer be available on the Google or Apple app stores.
People in the US who have downloaded the app would no longer be able to get downloads and it was likely to degrade without the ability to update “and TikTok may block US users before that happens to avoid further legal issues.”
Incoming President Donald Trump had vowed to save the app, but there was no clear legal method to do that, it said.
‘Top risks for 2025’
GZero Daily updates are produced by Eurasia Group, which is led by analyst Ian Bremmer. It says the TikTok verdict could be part of a breakdown of the US relationship with China, and that “Trump’s return to office is likely to exacerbate the decoupling — increasing the risk of instability and crisis.”
That is one of Bremmer’s Top Risks for 2025, as he says “We’re entering a uniquely dangerous period of world history on par with the 1930s and the early Cold War.”
His third top risk for the year is: “Trump’s return to office will unleash an unmanaged decoupling in the world’s most important geopolitical relationship.”
Read more here of Bremmer’s Top Risks for 2025.
NOTE: A minor edits were made to the text and headline on January 13, 2025.
ALSO SEE:
TikTok Ban: Supreme Court Case Begins, Billionaire Bids For App
Can Donald Trump Save TikTok From a Ban in the US?
If Legal Fight Fails, ByteDance ‘Would Prefer to Shut TikTok in US’
Forced Sale of TikTok is About Security, Not Free Speech, US Says
‘China Won’t Allow It’: TikTok Compares Divestiture to Chip Ban
Donald Trump Likely to Try to Block US TikTok Ban – WaPo
Trump Says He Will ‘Never Ban TikTok’ if Elected – NYPost
TikTok Hit by US Legal Barrage For ‘Harmful’ Impacts on Kids
Nearly Half of Gen Z Wish TikTok Was Never Invented: US Poll
EU MP: TikTok CEO ‘Must Explain Role in Romanian Poll’ – Politico
Canada Orders TikTok to Shut Offices in the Country – Reuters